Italian Wedding Caterers in Oyster Bay, NY

How do we sort results, including Sponsored Ads?

Caterers in Oyster Bay, NY

24 Wedding Caterers in Oyster Bay, NY

Italian
Clear
Quick responder
Platinum Party Planners & Catering

5.0

Massapequa, NY
  • Starts at $12,000

Platinum Party Planners is a full-service catering and event planning company. Our events are completely customized, we guide our clients through the planning process of selecting and designing a menu to reflect our clients’ vision. In addition, we can help you plan and design your event by selecting your event color palette, centerpieces, décor pieces etcetera. We will also coordinate with the best preferred/recommended vendors for all necessary rentals like tents, table, and chair styles and much more!! We will get every detail right on your most important day! We're with you every step of the way to ensure a flawless event.

I hired the Platinum Party Planner team to create a beautiful engagement party at my home this summer. From my first interaction with Tracy, I knew the experience would be outstanding; and I was right. From the planning all the way through the day of the event every detail was considered and taken care of. The communication was excellent, the food was incredible ( people are still talking about it ), the staff that arrived that day were top notch and I was able to be fully present and enjoy the experience with my family. The pictures from the day of the party reflect how we all felt that day and I believe Tracy and George really cared about our happiness and did everything possible to create a memorable day. Thank you to Tracy, George and the entire Platinum Party Planners team.
Linda, 7 months ago
Mill Creek Catering & Events
Bayville, NY
  • Starts at $75

Mill Creek Catering & Events is a premiere, full-service, off-premise caterer & event coordinator specializing in elegant, boutique weddings with a personalized touch. We are known for our inspirational, one of a kind events in spectacular locations with unsurpassed service. We help you to plan unique, seasonal menus designed to fit your vision and personal style, including cultural and ethnic trends. Our focus is on sustainability, and when possible, we use locally sourced ingredients. Our culinary team can accommodate an array of dietary needs.

Quick responder
Renegade Outpost

5.0

New York, NY
  • Starts at $4,000
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY

Renegade Outpost is a full service event planning and chef services company. We've been in business for 7 years and have been working with Thumbtack. We have been hired more than 290 times and have 160 5-star reviews. We offer logistical services as well as day/of coordination and securing rentals. Our "rolodex" includes many of the best vendors for all your event needs. Making your job easier is our highest priority. Wonderful food always begins with amazing ingredients, especially produce. We source directly from local farmers, we work with an organic butcher, a wild fish monger and importers of select cheese and specialty products.

Awarded Best of Zola
We hired chef Ellen/Renegade Outpost to provide all the food for my son's large engagement party in a cocktail lounge. They were so easy to deal with, unobtrusive when preparing and serving in a place that was not totally intended for such service, and everyone commented on how delicious and creative the food was! We felt very fortunate to have found them!
Elissa C., 2 years ago
Quick responder
Jillicious Foods & Events

5.0

Brooklyn, NY
  • Starts at $20,000
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY

Jillicious Foods is an all-in-one catering and event company dedicated to creating inspired, authentic wedding, social and corporate experiences. For us, every client represents a unique opportunity to tell a new and delicious story. Chef Jill has been telling these stories for nearly three decades. We work in a variety of cuisines, from New American to Cajun to Southeast Asian; accommodate all diets, including gluten-free, vegan, vegetarian, and pescatarian; and are proud to partner with local farms and purveyors throughout the Hudson Valley and New York City.

I can’t say enough about Jill and her team. From the first time we spoke, she just got us and understood exactly what we were looking for to celebrate my mothers 80th birthday. She really listened to what we wanted and created a fantastic menu. Not only was her food delicious, but she and her team were so warm and lovely and it was so nice to have them at our home and as part of the party!
Kathy Y., 2 years ago
Quick responder
Sunflowers Event Planning, Inc

5.0

Mastic Beach, NY
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY

With more then 25 years experience we find that listening to every bride and or client describe what they want for their special day or event is what it takes to be successful. It's what you want not what we want. Creativity is a strong characteristic and I enjoy the final product. It's simple. When the clients are happy I know we were to their expectations and that's all that matters at the end of the day.

We hired Sunflowers for our daughter's back yard wedding on Sept 12, 2020. Once Chef Laura and her crew arrived (hours before the event), they took over and I knew I was in good hands. Chef Laura was a pleasure to work with and also provided excellent guidance during the planning stages. The appetizers, passed during cocktail hour, looked and tasted great. All of the food during the buffet dinner was also excellent. The bar was well stocked with everything we needed for our crowd, which enjoys their cocktails. The crew were professional and responsive and kept everything clean during the party. Because of their hard work, I was able to enjoy the day! I will definitely call on Sunflowers for future events and would recommend them highly.
Rae, 3 years ago
Quick responder
Spices of the Sun
Woodland Park, NJ
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY

A native of Trinidad and Tobago, Nikisha Williams found her calling to cuisine at a very young age. In the Caribbean, it was commonplace to share large meals with family and friends made from ingredients picked outside your door and seasonal harvest feasts were shared with the entire community. Nikisha learned quickly that good, nourishing food was a blessing meant to be celebrated and she developed a passion for celebrating it.

Ginger Man Catering And Private Chef Service
Manhattan, NY
  • Starts at $75
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY

Ginger Man Catering is a Glatt Kosher catering company in NYC formed by Chef Oren to offer custom Kosher catering and personalized service to our clients, while based in NYC, Chef Oren and his exemplary team will travel throughout New York City, Long Island, Hamptons, New Jersey and Connecticut area to create your specialized event in your home or at the venue of your choice. Ginger Man Kosher Catering NYC will work directly with you to ensure every detail of your events fulfills your expectations and results in a successful and pleasurable event.

Belgiorno Family Mobile Wood Fired Pizza
Commack, NY
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY

It all began in the early 1900's when Carlo and Anna Belgiorno came to the United States from Naples, Italy. They brought with them a great dedication to family, a strong work ethic, and lastly a culture and passion of food; especially pizza.

Quick responder
Chef D Catering LLC

3.0

Las Vegas, NV
  • Starts at $2,000
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY for additional fees

Chef D Catering LLC is a premium catering and meal prep company, owned and operated by Chef DaVeon Whindleton. With over 12 years of experience in multiple cuisines, Chef DaVeon brings a wealth of knowledge and expertise to the table. With mouth-watering food and personalized services, Chef D Catering LLC is dedicated to bringing the best experience and delicious food into your home or event ! What We Offer * Catering Services: Chef D Catering LLC provides catering services for all occasions. Whether it's a small family gathering or a large corporate event, our experienced staff will make sure your guests are satisfied.

We had a wedding reception coming up and wanted it to be a bit fancier and more intimate than going to a restaurant. Chef D was able to fit us in at the last minute and his pricing was non-expensive he brought everything for the event and stayed the whole night. Highly recommend and look forward to using his services again
D W., 3 months ago
Quick responder
Late to the Lake

5.0

Grand Haven, MI
  • Starts at $450
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY for additional fees

Great taste is the name of the game and we're committed to stepping up to the plate. Our goal is provide unforgettable, delicious, and eye catching options. That's why we prepare all of our boards and graze displays to your style, with the highest quality products. Whether it is an intimate dinner or an event for up to 800 guests, we do it all! If you are considering a Graze table for your wedding or next event, reach out and we'd be delighted to create something beautiful for you!

Awarded Best of Zola
Alicia was SO easy to communicate with and created a delicious family style dinner for our wedding weekend. She was professional, warm, flexible, thoughtful, generous, and overall fantastic! Highly recommend! We also used Late to the Lake for a charcuterie spread at our welcome dinner, which was a huge hit!
Selena & Z., 8 months ago
Quick responder
Krisp Events

5.0

Brooklyn, NY
  • Starts at $4,000
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY for additional fees

Krisp Events is one of the top catering companies in New York. We bring to your party the best New York has to offer, using the finest seasonal and organic ingredients available. We pride ourselves on our international and eclectic menu and encourage suggestions for any customized menu requests. We pay very special attention to each event, and will gladly guide you through any planning to achieve the best possible experience for you and your guests. We look forward to providing you with a unique culinary event of excellence. Innovation combined with a strong work ethic is what makes Krisp who we are today.

Awarded Best of Zola
As a wedding planner many times I am managing vendors not only to confirm service but to prevent jeopardizing my clients event. Most of the time this can be frustrating especially when things are forgotten, coupled with many last minute changes, but not with Krisp Events. With Nora and Krisp Events I can close my eyes. It is important to be able to trust your vendors (especially Catering) without micromanaging. Their food is delicious, their staff is friendly, formal, and knowledgeable, and the administrative experience is seamless. Every event with Krisp, is a successful event.
Dana Butler Productions, 2 years ago
Quick responder
Chef Lemaire, LLC

5.0

Kissimmee, FL
  • Starts at $4,000
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY for additional fees

Award-wining Chef Alain Lemaire is a native of Port-au-Prince, Haiti, where he first discovered his interest in cooking. That interest in food grew out of the need to feed himself what he wanted, and when he wanted it by watching his mother and grandmother in the kitchen, to full blown passion by the time he graduated. Chef Lemaire has featured on several TV shows: he was the host chef of the “Taste of Haiti” episode of the "Luda Can't Cook" series on Discovery+ with award winning rapper, actor, restauranteur Chris "Ludacris" Bridges. He is also a contestant of the Food Network's hit series, Fire Masters, Cutthroat Kitchen, and Chopped.

Awarded Best of Zola
Chef Lemaire is simply amazing! He made our wedding experience one to remember. He took our food vision and truly made it a reality and beyond. I just love how he was down to earth, listened to us and personalized our menu to fit our needs and personalities. All of our guests said that the food looked super beautiful and tasted even more amazing! I can’t wait to have him do many more events for us in the near future. If you’re looking for someone who is detailed, orderly, and can bring all your visions to life, he is the one you want to book!
Jessica, 5 months ago
Quick responder
Noire Chef Boston

5.0

Westwood, MA
  • Starts at $8,000
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY for additional fees

Chef Nikia Spotts is a seasoned culinary professional with over a decade of experience in the food & hospitality industry. Her passion for food sparked at a young age & has only grown stronger over the years. She pursued her culinary aspirations by enrolling at Johnson & Wales University, where she attained a BS in Culinary Arts & Food Service Management and an MBA in Hospitality Management. Chef Nikia has an impressive professional background, having worked at renowned establishments such as The Catered Affair, Deuxave, Kate's Table, & Restaurant Associates.

Nikia and her team at Noire Chef Boston made my event perfect! From the delicious food, the incredible decor, and the organization of it all, everyone has been talking about how great of a party it was! All I had to do was share the vision with Nikia, and she perfected it. I’m so happy with how the party turned out, and would absolutely use Noire Chef Boston for any future events.
Morgan , a month ago
TrendlineTrending
Sensory Delights Catering

5.0

Pembroke Pines, FL
  • Starts at $6,000
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY for additional fees

Sensory Delights is a South Florida luxury boutique style catering company and your top destination for elegance, quality, and premium service for all occasions. From corporate events, to weddings, and social gatherings, we work hand in hand with you to make sure that all of your standards are met, and to make every occasion or event a thing to remember.

From my very first conversation with Chef Lemaire from Sensory Delights, I knew that they were the perfect vendors for our wedding. Sensory Delights offers a very creative menu and with very fair pricing. The whole team is highly professional; and they have a very thorough system in place to ensure a quality service. As the day approached, Neima was very helpful. She communicated with my wedding planner and also helped us tremendously the day of. As I was getting ready to walk down the aisles, Neima was helping with my dress as I was getting down the stairs. My husband and I chose the plated dinner and Let me tell you, that exceeded our expectations! Our guests kept calling after the wedding to compliment me as they were impressed with the food and services from the servers. One of the main highlights is how they made sure that my bridal party ate during the cocktails hour after the ceremony while taking our pictures. At the end of the night, they had boxed food for my husband and me for the next day. My wedding planner told me how they went the extra mile to make sure that they delivered. They exceeded our expectations. I cannot wait to work with them in the future. Thank you, Sensory Delights. You have gained a lifetime customer. Rose & Deldy
Rose and D., 3 years ago
Quick responder
Simply Delicious Dishes
Newark, DE
  • Starts at $2,000
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY for additional fees

We are a full service catering team that specializes in southern cuisine with a stylish flare! It is our passion and decorative attention to detail that has carried us for many years. We love what we do, and we will cater any event large or small with that same passion and service attention. We build strong lasting relationships with our clients, and take great pride in serving others. We also offer all inclusive services that cater to all your event preparations and needs. We take care of everything so that you don't have to!

Mangia and Enjoy!
Saugerties, NY
  • Starts at $25,000
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY for additional fees

Chef Sarah Chianese is an accomplished, award-winning chef & Wedding Industry Professional creating unique & memorable boutique wedding experiences for over a decade. She & her exceptional team at Mangia and Enjoy! provide the most flavorful, heart-warming, healthy and beautifully presented meals for you & your loved ones using local, organic & seasonal ingredients in a creative way - your experience, your palette's pleasure, and alway made with love! Local, organic, seasonal, farm fresh and full of Flavor! Mangia and Enjoy! has been featured in: Bridal Guide, Wedding Chicks, She Finds, Catersource, Dances With Her & more. WIPA, ICA & NACE.

Sam’s Spot
Westwood, MA
  • Starts at $5,000
  • Serves Oyster Bay, NY for additional fees

Sam's Spot is a premiere full-service catering company, We specialize in weddings and corporate events, but work with events of sorts. We intend for each and every guest to leave impressed by our food and presentation. We strive to create a stress-free and enjoyable evening. We take pride in injecting new life into the catering market through our culinary teams' innovative ideas, intensive culinary training and resourceful homemade style of cooking!

Dolce & Gelato Catering
Williston Park, NY

    Dolce & Gelato brings over a decade of experience in crafting unique flavors of smooth, creamy gelato and refreshing sorbets using only the highest quality ingredients. We cater events throughout New York City and the Tri-State Area. Choose from the widest selection of authentic flavors and make your next event 'one-of-a-kind'!

    Michael's Event Catering

    5.0

    Southampton, NJ
    • Starts at $2,000
    • Serves Oyster Bay, NY

    We are an off-premise, full service caterer, who specializes in custom weddings, with experienced and friendly service staff, along with food truck services. We strive to make your special day as stress free as possible by taking all the guess work out of rentals, set-up, food, staffing, etc. We will meet with you, help build a timeline for your event, take care of all your rental needs and execute with profession for a successful event! With our catering company, we bring the kitchen to you!

    They were so easy to work with and provided us with everything we needed to make our day what we wanted. Our wedding was postponed twice due to COVID, we decided to pull out of our venue, and have our wedding. We needed a bartender, food and servers. There bbq food was delicious, especially the Short Rib! Drinks were perfect! Absolutely loved the mobile kitchen to have everything prepared on site! 10/10 would recommend!
    Sara & M., 3 years ago
    Insatiable Eats Catering

    5.0

    Riverhead, NY
    • Starts at $3,750
    • Serves Oyster Bay, NY

    Insatiable Eats has catered countless events and weddings in the Hamptons, Long Island and New York since 2005. We pride ourselves in providing the highest level of cuisine using both locally sourced and special imported ingredients. Whether casual or formal, intimate or grand, our team of professional service staff make sure no details go unnoticed.

    Insatiable eats, catered the most important event of my life! My Wedding.. Their staff was attentive, the owners were present and wanted our input, the fact my husbands a Chef, He felt that they understood his vision with the food and decor!!! My being a bride and not feeling nervous was an actual plus... I loved the whole experience and would recommend their services to any and everyone!!!
    Evelyne R., 2 years ago
    Cento Percento

    5.0

    Brooklyn, NY
    • Starts at $2,100
    • Serves Oyster Bay, NY

    The phrase "cento percento" was born in the heart of Florence, Italy with the simple idea of bringing Tuscan style food to New York. It has since evolved into an experience like no other, including traditional antipasti, hot and cold main dishes, panini and decadent desserts, including pastries and soft serve gelato. Fresh ingredients and tradition are a reflection of Italy's love and passion for serving only the finest foods to their guests. At Cento Percento, we strive to uphold that tradition and provide you with a 100% (cento percento) unforgettable experience.

    I hired Cento Percento for several events for my clients and they were amazing to work with. The food is top notch and the service was impeccable. The staff understood the clientele and listened to my ideas and accommodated. They are very professional and a fun group to work with. I plan on using them whenever I have the opportunity.
    Carnegie Fabrics, 2 years ago
    Untraditional Eats
    Oakland, CA
    • Starts at $10,000
    • Serves Oyster Bay, NY

    Untraditional Eats was founded by a globe-trotting hyper polyglot who speaks 7 languages. That unparalleled exposure to different cultures, cuisines and ways of cooking, as well as an unmatched cultural sensitivity, makes us exceptionally great at what we do.

    The Rolling Gold
    Huntington, NY
    • Starts at $1,950
    • Serves Oyster Bay, NY

    The Rolling Gold is a mobile catering company on Long Island serving weddings and events. Our culinary team provides a delicious range of food and drinks from their vintage-inspired catering trucks equipped with state-of-the-art amenities. Whether seeking light refreshments to enjoy with cocktails or a buffet station for your reception dinner, they will provide mouthwatering dishes that leave a lasting impression. The Rolling Gold offers cuisines including Mexican, Italian, and American Southern as well as woodfire pizza, prepared from professional pizza ovens, which you can enjoy with freshly pulled beers from their taps.

    Pheasant

    5.0

    Brooklyn, NY
    • Serves Oyster Bay, NY for additional fees

    We LOVE weddings here at Pheasant! Being entrusted with one of the most important days of a couple’s life is not something we take lightly. After all, the bridal couple may be the focus of the day, but an amazing meal and impeccable service will make the entire event that much more memorable. Our knowledgeable staff will help guide you through the decision-making process as we go through menus, table scapes, furniture, timing, bar service and more together. We also have a strong rolodex of planners and florists that we work with on a regular basis - just ask us for more info!

    Working with Pheasant was the best decision we could have made for our wedding!!! Yes, it sounds cliché, but it is true. The title of this post is not even a joke; friends and family will-not-stop-talking-about-how-good-the-food-was-at-the-wedding...I'm like...hello? What about me, the bride? Our hilarious and heartfelt vows? The live band? Or even our surprise choreographed dance? Nope!! The food was the **true highlight** of the day/night. Although I may sound mad about it, I am not because it was absolutely delicious, stunning, fresh, and extremely memorable. The appetizers at cocktail hour, the raw bar, and the family style dinner was 10/10, 5 stars, 100%. Most brides and grooms don't even eat at their wedding because they are mingling...but, we had seconds and thirds with extra romesco sauce!!!! Working with Pheasant was hands down the easiest part of the whole wedding. Lola and Cat were incredibly quick to respond to emails, they went along with our requests and offered incredible suggestions. On top of all of that, they handled the rentals, collaborated with our florist and made the table setting romantic, dreamy, and very us 3 They also emotionally supported my decision when I switched event coordinators somewhat late in the game and they helped me find a better match. Lola and Cat were present and professional throughout our time together and then disappeared like fairy godmothers on the special day. They were there, because I vividly remember demanding a hug, but once the event started, they were working their magic on the backend and making sure we had the wedding of our dreams. I do not have a single complaint and I aim to be as honest as possible when writing reviews because it is what helped me make my decision when I was hiring vendors. Do yourself a favor, and hire Pheasant to cater your wedding and you and your guests can thank me later.
    Jack M., 2 years ago

    Location flexible? Discover caterers near Oyster Bay, NY

    About wedding catering in Oyster Bay, NY

    How much do catering services usually cost in Oyster Bay, NY?

    Full service catering packages range from $100 to $10,000 and average around $1,200.

    Which are the most popular caterers in Oyster Bay, NY?

    Some of the most popular caterers in this area include Infuse Catering & Events, Insatiable Eats Catering and Krisp Events.

    Do catering packages include serving staff?

    Yes! 37% of packages in Oyster Bay, NY include serving staff, such as servers and bussers. Many others also include rental coordination, just ask before you book!

    Can caterers in Oyster Bay, NY accommodate specialized diets?

    They can! 10 offer kosher services and 37 offer vegetarian packages. You can search on Zola for caterers who can accommodate nut-free, dairy-free, gluten-free, halal and vegan diets as well!

    What types of caterers are in Oyster Bay, NY?

    What other Oyster Bay vendors will I need?

    What other caterers are nearby?

    What other wedding services are nearby?